The Yinchuan Biennale

The contemporary art biennale of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region in north-west China, founded in 2016 at the Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan (MOCA Yinchuan) — the waa-designed Yellow River museum that is the first contemporary art museum of north-west China. Two editions to date: the inaugural For an Image, Faster than Light, curated by Bose Krishnamachari (2016), and Starting from the Desert: Ecologies on the Edge, curated by Marco Scotini (2018). The biennale is the institutional argument that the Sino-Islamic Silk Road geography, and the desert ecology of the Yellow River bend, are working subjects of the Chinese contemporary international.

Established2016 — 20182 editions
The Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan (MOCA Yinchuan) on the western bank of the Yellow River — designed by Beijing-based practice waa (we architech anonymous) and opened 2015 — the institutional home of the Yinchuan Biennale.
Above The Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan (MOCA Yinchuan) on the western bank of the Yellow River in the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region — designed by Beijing-based practice waa (we architech anonymous) and inaugurated in 2015 — the institutional home of the Yinchuan Biennale and, on its opening, the first museum of contemporary art in north-west China.

The Lead Essay The Yinchuan Biennale, 2016 – 2018

A biennale at the desert's edge

Founded 2016 at the waa-designed MOCA Yinchuan, the Yinchuan Biennale was constituted as the contemporary art institution of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region — the Muslim-majority province at the bend of the Yellow River where the historic Silk Road met the Mongolian steppe and the Gobi Desert. Across its first two editions, the programme has made the Sino-Islamic and the desert-ecological its working subjects: a curatorial argument unusual within the Chinese contemporary biennial system, and one held inside the museum that is, by its own institutional self-description, the first contemporary art museum of north-west China.

The Yinchuan Biennale opened on 10 September 2016 at the Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan, a year and three weeks after the museum itself opened to the public in August 2015. The biennale's first edition, For an Image, Faster than Light, was curated by the Mumbai-based Indian artist and curator Bose Krishnamachari — co-founder of the Kochi-Muziris Biennale and the inaugural artistic director of that institution's first edition in 2012 — and presented seventy-three artists from thirty-three countries across the museum's fifteen thousand square metres of exhibition space and into the surrounding ecological park. The curatorial argument was, in Krishnamachari's framing, an examination of spiritual and social consciousness inflected through the Sino-Islamic and pan-Asian geography in which the museum sits: the Yellow River bend that has, since the Tang dynasty, marked the institutional and ecological frontier between settled Chinese agriculture and the Mongolian-steppe and Central Asian routes of the historic Silk Road.

The second edition, Starting from the Desert: Ecologies on the Edge, opened on 9 June 2018 under the curatorship of the Italian critic and theorist Marco Scotini — then Head of the Visual Arts and Curatorial Studies Department at the Nuova Accademia di Belle Arti (NABA) in Milan and Artistic Director of the FM Center for Contemporary Art — with a curatorial team of Andris Brinkmanis, Paolo Caffoni, Zasha Colah and Lu Xinghua. The exhibition presented more than ninety artists across thirty-seven newly commissioned works and extended out from the museum's fifteen thousand square metres into the surrounding Hui Nongqu Eco-Park and the International Artist Village of the River Origins. Scotini organised the programme into four thematic sections — Nomadic Space and Rural Space, Labor-in-Nature and Nature-in-Labor, The Voice and The Book, and Minorities and Multiplicity — and made the working argument that the desert, in both its physical and its theoretical Deleuze-and-Guattari nomadological reading, was the contemporary subject the Yinchuan institution had been constituted to programme. The edition closed on 19 September 2018.

The institutional argument

The Yinchuan institution is unusual within the Chinese contemporary biennial system in three structural respects. The first is geographic: Yinchuan, capital of the Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, is one of five autonomous regions of the People's Republic and the only Chinese province-level entity with a Hui Muslim majority of historical and continuing institutional standing. The second is ecological: the museum sits at the precise geographical inflection where the Yellow River, on its great northward bend, divides lush irrigated wetland from the southern reach of the Gobi Desert — a site that no other major Chinese contemporary institution occupies. The third is architectural: waa's MOCA Yinchuan building, with its facade of more than 1,600 unique glass-reinforced gypsum panels referencing both the rigid strata of the Helan Mountains and the curved erosional patterns of the Yellow River, is one of the most ambitious museum-architecture commissions of the Chinese 2010s, and a continuing point of architectural-press reference (Architectural Review, ArchDaily, Dezeen, Designboom).

The biennale was constituted under the artistic direction of Suchen Hsieh — the founding artistic director of MOCA Yinchuan from its 2015 opening — whose curatorial argument, decided upon in August 2014 in advance of the museum's launch, was that the institution would focus on Sino-Islamic art: the only museum in China to adopt that self-definition, and the framing decision that distinguishes the Yinchuan programme from the many private contemporary art museums of the Chinese coastal east. The institution operates under a public-private partnership BOT (build-operate-transfer) model in which the land is held by the Yinchuan municipal government and the non-profit institution is owned and operated by the Ningxia Minsheng Group, a regional property developer. The biennale, in turn, has been programmed against the wider state-policy context of the Belt and Road Initiative — the Chinese international infrastructure programme inaugurated in 2013, which derives its naming from the ancient Silk Road and which has positioned the Ningxia region as a designated cultural and logistical node of the western corridor.


Critical Perspective Silk Road, state, Hui autonomy

A Sino-Islamic biennale under PRC state cultural authority

The Yinchuan Biennale is the only continuing Chinese international biennial that has made the Sino-Islamic Silk Road and the desert ecology of the Hui Autonomous Region its constituting curatorial subject. The institutional question is what it means to programme an explicitly transnational Silk Road argument inside the continuing cultural authority of the People's Republic of China — and how the biennale's first two editions navigated, with their non-Chinese curatorial choices, the working boundary between regional-Hui specificity and central state framing.

The Chinese contemporary biennial system, as it has consolidated across the 2010s, is concentrated on the eastern coastal axis: the Shanghai Biennale (founded 1996 at the Power Station of Art), the Guangzhou Triennial (founded 2002 at the Guangdong Museum of Art), the Beijing Biennale (founded 2003 under the China Artists Association), the Shenzhen Biennale of Urbanism\Architecture (founded 2005), and the Shenzhen Sculpture Biennale at OCT Contemporary Art Terminal. Within that field, the Yinchuan Biennale's structural position is unambiguous: it is the only continuing Chinese contemporary biennial sited in the inland west, the only one held in an autonomous region rather than in a province or a directly-administered municipality, and the only one whose institutional self-framing has made the Sino-Islamic and the Silk Road its constituting subject rather than a peripheral programmatic theme.

The institutional question that the Yinchuan programme raises — and that the critical literature, from Hanlu Zhang's Artforum reporting on the inaugural edition to the OnCurating issue 46 essay on the biennale and the Belt and Road Initiative, has taken as its working subject — is the question of what it means to programme an explicitly transnational Silk Road and Sino-Islamic argument inside the continuing cultural authority of the People's Republic of China. The Belt and Road Initiative, announced by Xi Jinping in 2013 and adopted as principal state foreign-policy frame across the second half of the decade, has positioned the Ningxia region as a designated node of the western corridor: the China-Arab States Expo has been held biennially in Yinchuan since 2013, and the wider state argument has been that the city's Hui-Muslim demographic and its position on the historic Silk Road make it the natural Chinese institutional interlocutor for the wider Islamic world. The biennale operates inside that state framing.

The curatorial choices of the first two editions — an Indian curator from the Kochi-Muziris Biennale programming the inaugural, an Italian curator from NABA Milan programming the second — are themselves the institutional argument the biennale makes against any reduction of the programme to a domestic Chinese exercise in state cultural diplomacy. Krishnamachari's 2016 edition drew principally on a South-and-Central-Asian and South-American curatorial network (the Kochi connection visibly extending into the Yinchuan programme); Scotini's 2018 edition drew on the European postcolonial-theory and ecological-criticism networks (the wider exhibition pulling in references from Deleuze and Guattari's nomadology, the Italian Autonomia tradition and the contemporary land-art and rural-design fields). Both editions extended their programmes physically out of the museum and into the surrounding agricultural and ecological park, treating the desert-and-wetland edge as the actual subject of the exhibition rather than as its picturesque backdrop.

The institutional question the Yinchuan programme continues to pose — the question against which any future third edition will be read — is whether the curatorial argument can be sustained as the Belt and Road framing has tightened, as the wider Chinese cultural environment has become more centrally administered across the 2020s, and as the international biennial circuit has reorganised around different geopolitical axes. The two editions that exist are a working demonstration that the Sino-Islamic Silk Road argument is curatorially possible inside the Chinese institutional field. What the institution's next move is will be the next chapter of the Yinchuan record.


The Institutional Spine

Defining moments

Five episodes from the founding of MOCA Yinchuan and the first two editions of the biennale.

2015Museum

waa's MOCA Yinchuan opens

The Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan, designed by the Beijing-based practice waa (we architech anonymous) — founded 2010 by Di Zhang, Jack Young and Ruben Bergambagt after they met working at Foster + Partners — opened to the public in August 2015 on the western bank of the Yellow River. The fifteen-thousand-square-metre museum was, by its own institutional description, the first contemporary art museum of north-west China; its facade of more than 1,600 unique glass-reinforced gypsum panels references both the rigid strata of the Helan Mountains and the curved erosional patterns of the Yellow River, and the project was commended by the Architectural Review's Emerging Architecture Awards. The museum opened with an inaugural exhibition titled Civilization and Future, framing the Silk Road geography as its constituting subject.

Sources: ArchDaily; Architectural Review; The Art Newspaper

2016I

Krishnamachari's For an Image, Faster than Light

The inaugural Yinchuan Biennale, curated by the Indian artist and Kochi-Muziris Biennale co-founder Bose Krishnamachari, opened on 10 September 2016 and ran through 18 December 2016. The exhibition presented seventy-three artists from thirty-three countries — including Anish Kapoor, Yoko Ono, Liam Gillick, Mary Ellen Carroll, Liu Wei, Cao Fei, Ivan Navarro, Santiago Sierra, Slavs and Tatars and Song Dong — and made the curatorial argument that the contemporary image, in its acceleration past the speed of light of older communication, demands an examination of spiritual and social consciousness and an acknowledgement of collective responsibility. The edition extended across the museum's fifteen thousand square metres and into the surrounding ecological park.

Sources: e-flux; Biennial Foundation; Universes in Universe

2016Critical reception

Hanlu Zhang in Artforum: "Regional Affairs"

The Beijing-based critic Hanlu Zhang's reporting on the inaugural Yinchuan Biennale for Artforum, published in the magazine's diary and columns under the title Regional Affairs, set the principal critical frame against which subsequent writing on the biennale has been read: that the Yinchuan project is to be understood as the cultural-institutional counterpart of the Belt and Road Initiative, with the inland west's long search for an economic and cultural position against the eastern coast finding, in the biennale and its museum, a working international platform. The framing was extended in the OnCurating issue 46 essay The Yinchuan Biennale: The Belt and Road Initiative and the Artistic Practices Linking East and West.

Sources: Artforum diary; OnCurating, Issue 46

2018II

Scotini's Starting from the Desert

The second Yinchuan Biennale, Starting from the Desert: Ecologies on the Edge, opened on 9 June 2018 under the curatorship of the Italian critic and theorist Marco Scotini, with a curatorial team of Andris Brinkmanis, Paolo Caffoni, Zasha Colah and Lu Xinghua. The exhibition presented thirty-seven newly commissioned works by more than ninety artists across four thematic sections — Nomadic Space and Rural Space, Labor-in-Nature and Nature-in-Labor, The Voice and The Book, and Minorities and Multiplicity — and extended out from the fifteen-thousand-square-metre museum into the Hui Nongqu Eco-Park and the International Artist Village of the River Origins. The desert, in its Deleuze-and-Guattari nomadological reading, served as both physical and theoretical starting point. The edition closed on 19 September 2018.

Sources: e-flux; Ocula; Studio International

2018Catalogue

The Mousse catalogue and the institutional record

The catalogue of the second edition, Second Yinchuan Biennale: Starting from the Desert. Ecologies on the Edge, was published by Mousse Publishing in Milan under the editorial direction of Marco Scotini and the curatorial team — the institutional record-setting that, in the absence of a third edition to date, has held the biennale's argument as a published reference within the international biennial-criticism literature. The Mousse catalogue, together with the Apollo, Spike and Studio International reviews from summer 2018, constitutes the principal published record of the Yinchuan programme available outside Chinese-language sources.

Sources: Mousse Publishing; Apollo Magazine; Spike Art Magazine

People in the Yinchuan programme

The figures behind Yinchuan

Curator · I (2016)

Bose Krishnamachari

Indian artist, curator and arts administrator, born Kerala 1963; trained at Sir J.J. School of Art, Mumbai (1986–1991) and Goldsmiths, University of London (1999–2000). Co-founder of the Kochi-Muziris Biennale and Artistic Director and Co-Curator of its inaugural 2012 edition; Director of the 2014 edition and continuing President of the Kochi Biennale Foundation through January 2026. Curator of the inaugural Yinchuan Biennale, For an Image, Faster than Light, in 2016 — the institutional moment at which an Indian curatorial voice opened a Chinese contemporary international.

Source: Wikipedia; ArtReview, 2016; Universes in Universe

Curator · II (2018)

Marco Scotini

Italian critic, curator and theorist; Head of the Visual Arts and Curatorial Studies Department at the Nuova Accademia di Belle Arti (NABA) in Milan from 2004 to 2025, when he was named NABA Artistic Director; Artistic Director of the FM Center for Contemporary Art in Milan. Founder of the bookzine No Order: Art in a Post-Fordist Society. Curator of the Albanian Pavilion at the 56th Venice Biennale (2015), co-curator of the 1st Anren Biennale (2017), and Artistic Director of the Second Yinchuan Biennale, Starting from the Desert: Ecologies on the Edge, in 2018.

Source: NABA faculty; Biennial Foundation, 2017; Universes in Universe

Artistic Director · MOCA Yinchuan

Suchen Hsieh

Founding artistic director of the Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan from its opening in 2015 and continuing institutional voice across the first two editions of the Yinchuan Biennale. The decision, taken in August 2014 in advance of the museum's launch, that the institution would focus on Sino-Islamic art — the only museum in China to adopt that self-definition — is the framing curatorial argument under which the wider biennale programme has been constituted. Hsieh's earlier curatorial work includes the international animation art exhibition Very Addictive — Re-Extension of Aesthetics in Daily Life.

Source: The Art Newspaper, 2015; e-flux

Architects · MOCA Yinchuan, 2015

waa (we architech anonymous)

Beijing-based architectural practice founded 2010 by Di Zhang, Jack Young and Ruben Bergambagt, who met at Foster + Partners in London. The MOCA Yinchuan commission, opened 2015 on the western bank of the Yellow River, is the practice's principal cultural-building project to date and the institutional architectural argument of the Yinchuan Biennale. The facade of more than 1,600 unique glass-reinforced gypsum panels — referencing both the rigid strata of the Helan Mountains and the curved erosional patterns of the Yellow River — was commended by the Architectural Review's Emerging Architecture Awards and has been continuously cited across the international architectural press (ArchDaily, Dezeen, Designboom, Divisare).

Source: ArchDaily; Dezeen, 2015; Designboom

Founded
2016 · Yinchuan, Ningxia
Institution
MOCA Yinchuan
Frequency
Biennial (2 editions to date)
Architect
waa (we architech anonymous), 2015
Region
Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region

Geography

The Yinchuan Biennale at the Yellow River bend

Principal venues

Museum of Contemporary Art Yinchuan (MOCA Yinchuan)

Designed by waa (we architech anonymous), opened August 2015 — the institutional home of the Yinchuan Biennale and the first contemporary art museum of north-west China. Fifteen thousand square metres of exhibition space on the west bank of the Yellow River.

Hetao Cultural Park
Hedong Road, Xingqing District
Yinchuan, Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region, China

Hui Nongqu Eco-Park

Organic agricultural and ecological park surrounding the MOCA Yinchuan museum, programmed as an extension of the 2018 biennale's Starting from the Desert across its four thematic sections — the working site of the biennale's desert-and-wetland edge argument.

Surrounding the MOCA Yinchuan museum complex
Hetao Cultural Park, Xingqing District
Yinchuan, Ningxia, China

International Artist Village of the River Origins

Artist residency and exhibition compound established as the third programmatic anchor of the second Yinchuan Biennale in 2018 — the institutional argument that the biennale operates not as a single-museum event but as a wider west-bank Yellow River cultural geography.

Adjacent to MOCA Yinchuan
Hetao Cultural Park
Yinchuan, Ningxia, China

From the Directory

Related Chinese and Silk Road biennials

Browse the region →

Essential Reading

For further work

For an Image, Faster than Light — 1st Yinchuan Biennale

Bose Krishnamachari, curator  ·  2016

Catalogue of the inaugural edition, presenting seventy-three artists from thirty-three countries at MOCA Yinchuan from 10 September to 18 December 2016.

Second Yinchuan Biennale: Starting from the Desert. Ecologies on the Edge

Marco Scotini, ed.  ·  Mousse Publishing, 2018

Catalogue of the second edition, published by Mousse Publishing in Milan: the principal published record of the Yinchuan programme outside Chinese-language sources.

"Regional Affairs" — Hanlu Zhang on the Yinchuan Biennale

Hanlu Zhang  ·  Artforum, 2016

The Beijing-based critic's reporting on the inaugural edition — the diary essay that set the Belt-and-Road critical frame against which subsequent writing on the biennale has been read.

"The Yinchuan Biennale: The Belt and Road Initiative and the Artistic Practices Linking East and West"

OnCurating, Issue 46  ·  2020

Long-form essay extending the critical frame from Hanlu Zhang's reporting and examining the biennale's relation to the wider Chinese state cultural-policy framing of the Belt and Road Initiative.

"Material culture: MOCA by Waa in Yinchuan, China"

Architectural Review  ·  2015

Architectural-press review of the waa-designed museum on its opening — the principal English-language record of the building's facade, its glass-reinforced gypsum panels and its Yellow River reference.

Editorial content on biennale.com is published by the Biennale Editorial Team. Image credits as captioned. External links are provided for reference and verification.