The Human Residue: Why Art Matters in an Age of Endless Creation

In the face of infinite synthetic beauty, the value of art lies not in its final product, but in its process

There is a particular kind of silence that settles over a certain type of art gallery in 2025. It is not the contemplative hush of a chapel, but the slightly baffled quiet of an audience faced with a spectacle of immense technical virtuosity and a profound affective void. On the walls are vast, luminous images, impossibly detailed and flawlessly rendered.

Listen closely, though, and the conversations in these spaces are telling. There is less talk of emotion or meaning, and more of process and prompts. "The artist's craft," a gallerist might explain, "lies in the construction of the descriptive text, in the artful layering of generative models." The artist, in this new paradigm, is not a maker of images but a whispered collaborator with a ghost in the machine.

"Art has become a vital, even necessary, human practice: a ritual for reclaiming our attention, a space for navigating complexity, and a way of leaving a verifiable trace of our existence."

We are living through an unprecedented epistemological crisis, a moment of profound vertigo brought on by the sudden rise of synthetic media. The tools to generate plausible text, imagery, and sound are now ubiquitous, dissolving the traditional link between a creative work and a human creator.

The German critic Walter Benjamin, writing in the 1930s, argued that mechanical reproduction diminished a work of art's "aura"—its unique presence in time and space. What we face now is a crisis of aura on an exponential scale. If Benjamin was concerned with the photograph's ability to detach an artwork from its original context, we are confronted with artworks that have no original context to begin with.

This is why a visit to a painter's studio, a potter's workshop, or a sculptor's foundry can feel like such a tonic in 2025. To witness the physical evidence of human labor—the smudges of charcoal on a canvas, the faint imprint of a thumb in a clay pot—is to be reminded that art can be a form of proof. Each mark represents a decision, a moment of hesitation, a flash of confidence, a correction.

This "human residue" has become the new aura. The appeal of a heavily impastoed painting is no longer just a matter of texture; it is a declaration of labor against the frictionless output of the algorithm. The slight asymmetry of a hand-thrown vase is not a flaw; it is the signature of a human nervous system.

In this context, the act of engaging with a significant work of art becomes a powerful counter-practice. To spend twenty minutes in front of a Mark Rothko painting is to enter a different temporal reality. The work does not reveal itself in an instant. It requires a quietening of the mind, an adjustment of the eye, and a willingness to let an experience unfold at its own pace.

The art that matters in 2025, then, is the art that demands something of us. It is valuable not because it is perfect, but because it is imperfect—because it bears the indelible, un-simulatable trace of human intention. This is the human residue: the evidence of a mind struggling to give form to an idea, of a body moving through space, of a consciousness paying attention to the world.

Latest Biennial News

From the Art World

The Global List: Your Guide to the 2025 Art Biennials & Triennials

2025 has proven to be a blockbuster year for large-scale international art exhibitions

From the deserts of California to the mountains of Japan, a dense calendar of biennials and triennials is shaping the global art conversation. As we cross the midpoint of the year, we've compiled your essential guide to the key events of 2025.

Winter/Spring 2025 Recap: The year began with Sharjah Biennial 16, curated by Natasha Ginwala, Amal Khalaf, and Zeynep Öz, continuing its legacy of championing artists from the Global South. Desert X 2025 returned to the California desert with ambitious site-specific installations, while the Toronto Biennial engaged with Indigenous perspectives and Great Lakes histories.

Summer 2025: Helsinki Biennial continues on Vallisaari island with its focus on ecological themes. The Echigo-Tsumari Art Triennale unfolds across 760 square kilometers of rural Japan—one of the world's largest art festivals. The 18th Venice Architecture Biennale explores pressing topics of sustainability and geopolitics.

Autumn/Winter 2025 Highlights: The 36th Bienal de São Paulo makes history with curation by a collective of Indigenous curators. Performa 25 transforms New York into a stage for cutting-edge performance art. Aichi Triennale 2025 delivers cross-disciplinary exhibitions across Nagoya. Asia Pacific Triennial (APT11) at QAGOMA offers an unparalleled overview of the region. MOMENTA Biennale explores contemporary photography in Montreal, while GIBCA tackles complex themes in Gothenburg.

"In a historic move, the curation has been entrusted to a collective of Indigenous curators. This decision signals a radical shift in perspective."

Remembering Koyo Kouoh, The Curator Who Built a New Center of Gravity

The visionary who irrevocably shifted the global conversation around contemporary African art

The art world is in mourning today for the loss of Koyo Kouoh, the visionary curator, institution-builder, and fierce intellectual who irrevocably shifted the global conversation around contemporary African art. Kouoh, who passed away recently after a brief illness, was the Executive Director and Chief Curator of the Zeitz Museum of Contemporary Art Africa (Zeitz MOCAA) in Cape Town.

"The greatest poverty is the poverty of knowledge. An image without its context, without its history, is an orphan. My work is to give these works their family, their home."

— Koyo Kouoh

To say Koyo Kouoh championed African artists is to state the obvious. Her profound contribution was not merely to show their work, but to build the very architecture—intellectual, physical, and discursive—that would ensure its analysis, preservation, and understanding on its own terms. She refused to plead for a seat at the Western art world's table; instead, she built a new table, in Africa, and in doing so, created a new center of gravity for the entire art world.

Born in Cameroon and educated in Europe, she could have easily pursued a comfortable career within established Western institutions. Instead, she chose Dakar, Senegal, for her life's foundational project. In 2008, she founded RAW Material Company, a space that defiantly resisted easy categorization. It was a gallery, yes, but also a residency, a library, a publishing house, and a crucible for conversation.

Her appointment to lead Zeitz MOCAA in 2019 was seen as a pivotal moment—a test of whether the radical, independent spirit of RAW could scale to the level of a multi-million-dollar, continent-defining museum. Kouoh met the challenge with her signature blend of pragmatism and vision. She stabilized the institution, deepened its connection to the local community, and sharpened its Pan-African focus.

Koyo Kouoh did not just participate in the art world; she remade it in a more intelligent, equitable, and globally conscious image. The center of gravity she created continues to hold, and her work, through the institutions she built and the minds she shaped, is far from over.

The 2025 Biennale Grand Tour

Forget art fair fatigue. These are the ten essential cultural pilgrimages of the year

In the ever-churning waters of the contemporary art world, the biennial remains a singular beast. Less nakedly transactional than an art fair, and more ambitious than a museum blockbuster, the biennial is where careers are anointed, intellectual currents are tested, and the global art-world flock gathers.

1. The Whitney Biennial, New York (Spring 2025)
Curated by Sofia Hernandez Chong Cuy & Maura Reilly. America's cultural lightning rod returns. Expect a rigorously researched, fiercely feminist, and politically pointed exhibition. Opening night remains the hottest ticket in the New York spring season.

2. Sharjah Biennial 16, UAE (Spring 2025)
While Dubai builds the world's tallest everything, Sharjah has built the most important art exhibition in the Middle East. Under Hoor Al Qasimi's direction, it champions post-colonial, South-South dialogue. This isn't about flipping work—it's where major institutions come to spot gaps in their collections.

3. The 17th Istanbul Biennial (Autumn 2025)
No biennial navigates a more complex political landscape. Rumors swirl around the appointment of filmmaker Deniz Tortum as curator. Watch local powerhouses SALT and Arter for parallel programming.

4. La Biennale de Lyon (Autumn 2025)
Curated by Cédric Fauq. Lyon is the quirky, fiercely independent cousin to Paris. The 2025 edition revolves around "alchemy"—expect transformations, unexpected materialities, and a healthy dose of the surreal.

5. Gwangju Biennale, South Korea (Autumn 2025)
Nicolas Bourriaud takes the helm at Asia's oldest biennial. The theorist behind "Relational Aesthetics" brings a philosophically rigorous perspective. With Seoul now an art market capital, international collectors will descend in force.

Plus: São Paulo's Indigenous collective curation, Prospect.6 in New Orleans, Helsinki's winter edition, Taipei Biennial's tech focus, and Performa 25's live art extravaganza round out the essential ten.

The Ghost and the Machine: Why Performa 25 Is New York's Most Urgent Exhibition

In a world saturated by digital replication, Performa's insistence on the live moment has become a radical act

The New York air in July hangs thick and heavy, but beneath the surface, a different energy is building for the city's most defiantly ephemeral event. This autumn, Performa 25 returns. And in 2025, the biennial dedicated to live performance is not just another date on the cultural calendar; it's an urgent, necessary confrontation with the very nature of our contemporary existence.

The central medium of performance art has always been the body, but the context of that body has profoundly changed. Performa 25 will be one of the first editions fully conceived in the wake of a global pandemic that made shared air a liability and physical presence a risk. This isn't a historical footnote; it's the foundational context for every commission.

"The question is no longer simply 'what does it mean to be live?' but 'what have we learned—and lost—about liveness itself?'"

While other art forms grappled with digital pivots, performance was the one medium whose essence—co-presence—was fundamentally threatened. Expect the artists of Performa 25 to interrogate this new reality with ferocious intelligence. Look for works that explore the politics of breath, the permeability of personal space, and the renewed, almost sacred, aura of a crowd gathered in a single room.

What makes the current moment particularly significant is how it reflects broader challenges facing international art institutions operating in politically fraught contexts. The controversy over Ayas's rejection—widely believed to be connected to her refusal to deny the Armenian genocide while curating Turkey's 2015 Venice Biennale pavilion—highlighted how historical memory and contemporary politics continue to shape cultural production in Turkey.

Yet the crisis has also generated unexpected opportunities. The open call for artists announced for the 2025 edition marks the first time in over a decade that the Istanbul Biennial has adopted this more democratic approach to artist selection. The formation of a new advisory board with clearer regulations about curator selection suggests an institution attempting to rebuild trust through transparency.

Think of it as a temporal mapping of New York's performance DNA. A commission in a Judson-era Greenwich Village church converses with the ghosts of 1960s dance theater. A piece in a raw Bronx warehouse taps into hip-hop's birth. A Financial District skyscraper speaks to the invisible choreography of capital.

The Heartbeat of the Megalopolis: Inside the Radical Promise of the 36th Bienal de São Paulo

How Antropofagia—cultural cannibalism—shapes Brazil's revolutionary approach to the global biennial

In the sprawling concrete megalopolis of São Paulo, the Bienal is more than an art exhibition. It is the city's cultural heartbeat made visible. Every two years, the art world's gaze shifts to Oscar Niemeyer's iconic pavilion in Ibirapuera Park. But the Bienal radiates outwards, electrifying the city's galleries, studios, and intellectual life.

To understand the Bienal de São Paulo, you must first understand Antropofagia—cultural cannibalism. Coined by poet Oswald de Andrade in 1928, this audacious idea proposed that Brazil's cultural strength lay not in rejecting foreign influence, but in devouring it, digesting it, and metabolizing it into something fiercely Brazilian.

"This is no mere gesture of inclusion. It is a fundamental dismantling of the colonial curatorial model."

For the first time, curation has been entrusted to a collective of Indigenous curators, with artist Denilson Baniwa as a central figure. This appointment signals a deliberate move away from the traditional Western art-historical framework. The conversations happening are not about formalism or market trends, but about land, territory, ancestral knowledge, and non-human temporalities.

The Paulistano Art Ecosystem:

The Blue-Chip Bastion (Jardins/Cerqueira César): Stroll down Rua Oscar Freire to find Galeria Nara Roesler, Mendes Wood DM, and Fortes D'Aloia & Gabriel—where you feel the pulse of the art world's top tier.

The Bohemian Heart (Vila Madalena/Pinheiros): Home to Galeria Leme in Paulo Mendes da Rocha's striking building, buzzing with younger, experimental energy.

The Historic Core (Centro): Inside Niemeyer's Copan building, Pivô is one of Brazil's most exciting non-profit art spaces.

This autumn, the 36th Bienal promises to be more than a survey of contemporary art. It will be an argument for a different way of seeing, of relating, of being in the world.

Five Curators Defining the Conversation

The visionaries whose intellectual projects and institutional influence demand our attention

In an art world saturated with blockbuster shows, the curator has evolved far beyond the role of a mere caretaker of objects. Today, they are cultural producers, public intellectuals, and the architects of the conversations that define our time.

1. Denilson Baniwa — The artist-curator as revolutionary. As a key figure in São Paulo's all-Indigenous curatorial collective, Baniwa challenges the very idea of the Western exhibition model, working instead with Indigenous cosmologies and land-based knowledge.

2. Vivian Crockett — The institutional insider building a more inclusive American canon at New York's New Museum. She doesn't just include artists of color; she curates their work with a depth that re-centers their importance to modernism and contemporary art.

3. Cédric Fauq — The generational voice capturing emerging European art's surreal energy at CAPC Bordeaux. His exhibitions embrace mythology, identity, and contemporary surrealism, capturing the zeitgeist of a generation navigating porous realities.

4. Marina Otero Verzier — The interdisciplinary thinker dissolving boundaries between art, architecture, and research. Her work on labor, resource extraction, and digital architecture is agenda-setting for our ecological and technological moment.

5. Vipash Purichanont — The regional connector foregrounding Southeast Asia. As co-curator of the 2022 Bangkok Art Biennale, he articulates the region's contemporary art scene on its own terms, with deep historical research and political context.

Concrete Canvases: The 10 New York Artists Who Built the Modern Art World

A chronological journey through the seismic artistic forces that made New York the capital of contemporary art

New York City is more than a backdrop for art history; it's a co-conspirator. It's the crucible where ambition, grit, and genius are forged into new ways of seeing. For over a century, artists have flocked here not just to make art, but to have it out with the very idea of art itself. They came to break rules, invent new languages, and, in the process, knock Paris off its pedestal as the undisputed capital of the art world.

To be an influential New York artist means more than being successful. It means you changed the conversation. Your work became a new foundation upon which others had to build, or a wall against which they had to rebel. What follows is not a definitive "best of" list, but a chronological journey through ten of the most seismic artistic forces to ever call this city home—figures whose ideas still ripple through every gallery, museum, and studio today.

1. Marcel Duchamp (1887-1968)

The Academic Angle: Duchamp is the philosophical ghost in New York's machine. Arriving from France in 1915, he didn't just show the city new art; he fundamentally rewired its definition of art. With his "readymades"—mass-produced objects like a urinal (Fountain) or a bottle rack that he designated as art—he proposed that the artist's idea and choice were more important than technical skill. This act of conceptual insurgency is the bedrock of virtually all conceptual art, performance art, and institutional critique that followed. He made the question "But is it art?" the central drama of the 20th century.

Quirky Fact: After seemingly abandoning the art world, Duchamp spent over two decades secretly working on his final masterpiece, Étant donnés, a shocking and voyeuristic diorama only visible through two peepholes in a wooden door, now at the Philadelphia Museum of Art. For years, his New York neighbors and friends simply thought his primary occupation was playing tournament-level chess.

2. Jackson Pollock (1912-1956)

The Academic Angle: If Duchamp was the mind, Pollock was the body. As the leading figure of Abstract Expressionism, he created a new kind of pictorial space. His "drip" paintings, made by pouring and flinging paint onto unprimed canvas on the floor of his Long Island studio, were not pictures of an experience; they were the record of an experience. This "all-over" composition, with no central focus, and the emphasis on the physical process of creation—what critic Harold Rosenberg famously dubbed "action painting"—made New York the white-hot center of the art world.

Quirky Fact: Pollock was notoriously hostile towards explaining his work. When a perplexed viewer once asked him, "How do you know when you're finished?" he famously growled back, "How do you know when you're finished making love?"

3. Willem de Kooning (1904-1997)

The Academic Angle: De Kooning was the great painterly wrestler of the New York School. While Pollock dove into pure abstraction, de Kooning thrashed violently between abstraction and figuration, most famously in his terrifying and brilliant Woman series. His canvases are battlegrounds of addition and subtraction, with aggressive brushwork and a palpable sense of struggle. He proved that abstraction wasn't a one-way street and that the human figure could be dissected and reassembled with ferocious, modern energy.

Quirky Fact: To slow the drying time of his oil paints, allowing him to endlessly rework his canvases, de Kooning mixed in unconventional binders like safflower oil and even, according to lore, mayonnaise. His studio floor was often a treacherous landscape of discarded, wet paintings he called his "slipping glimpse."

"To be an influential New York artist means more than being successful. It means you changed the conversation."

4. Jasper Johns (b. 1930)

The Academic Angle: Johns is the brilliant bridge connecting the hot emotion of Abstract Expressionism to the cool irony of Pop Art and Minimalism. Arriving in New York, he began painting things "the mind already knows," like flags, targets, and numbers. By meticulously rendering these flat, familiar symbols in sensuous encaustic (pigmented hot wax), he asked profound questions: Is this a flag, or a painting of a flag? Where does the object end and the art begin? This cerebral, deadpan approach opened the door for a generation of artists to explore the gap between signs and meaning.

Quirky Fact: The idea for his most famous work, Flag (1954-55), came to him in a dream. He was so shaken by its clarity that he got up the next day, went out and bought the materials, and began the painting that would change his life and art history.

5. Andy Warhol (1928-1987)

The Academic Angle: No artist is more synonymous with the New York art world's glamour, commerce, and conceptual power. Warhol completely erased the line between fine art and commercial culture. Using the mechanical process of silkscreening, he reproduced images of Campbell's Soup cans, Coca-Cola bottles, and celebrities like Marilyn Monroe, draining them of their original context and transforming them into flat, potent icons. His studio, The Factory, was a legendary social hub that blurred the lines between artist, assistant, superstar, and voyeur, effectively creating the template for the modern artist as a brand and media manipulator.

Quirky Fact: Warhol was a compulsive collector and hoarder. For the last 13 years of his life, he created "Time Capsules"—612 standard-sized cardboard boxes into which he tossed daily ephemera, from taxi receipts and pizza dough to celebrity snapshots and fan letters, sealing them up and putting them in storage.

6. Diane Arbus (1923-1971)

The Academic Angle: Arbus's camera turned not to the city's landmarks, but to its soul. She was a connoisseur of the liminal, the strange, and the overlooked. Her stark, square-format portraits of giants, twins, nudists, and everyday New Yorkers are confrontational and deeply empathetic. She rejected the "decisive moment" of street photography for a more unsettling, collaborative portrait where the subject is acutely aware of being seen. This psychological intensity created a new, influential language for portrait photography that was less about capturing a moment and more about revealing a state of being.

Quirky Fact: To break the ice with her often marginalized subjects, Arbus had a knack for making them feel seen and respected. One of her techniques was to confess her own feelings of strangeness or otherness, creating an immediate, if temporary, bond of shared humanity.

7. Donald Judd (1928-1994)

The Academic Angle: Judd took art off the wall and threw away the pedestal. As a leading theorist and artist of Minimalism, he rejected the illusion and emotion of painting in favor of what he called "specific objects." Working with industrial materials like aluminum, plywood, and Plexiglas, he created stark, serialized forms—often simple boxes or "stacks"—that asserted their own physical reality. His work forces the viewer to confront the object itself, its material, and its relationship to the surrounding space. He almost single-handedly turned the industrial lofts of SoHo into the pristine, "white cube" gallery aesthetic.

Quirky Fact: Judd despised the term "Minimalism," finding it lazy and dismissive. He was notoriously precise about language and installation, writing extensive essays and often providing exact instructions on how his works should be fabricated and displayed, down to the last millimeter.

"New York City is more than a backdrop for art history; it's a co-conspirator. It's the crucible where ambition, grit, and genius are forged into new ways of seeing."

8. Jean-Michel Basquiat (1960-1988)

The Academic Angle: Basquiat was a lightning strike. In less than a decade, he went from a homeless graffiti artist spraying enigmatic phrases under the tag SAMO© to the radiant child of the 1980s neo-expressionist art boom. His canvases are a raw, explosive fusion of art history, anatomical drawings, poetic text, and critiques of racism and colonialism. He brought the energy of the street and the intellectualism of a voracious autodidact into the gallery, creating a visual language that was immediate, complex, and utterly his own.

Quirky Fact: To fuel his frenetic creative process, Basquiat would often work on multiple paintings at once, with televisions blaring, music blasting, and books open all over his studio floor. He famously painted in expensive Armani suits, which would become splattered with paint, treating them as just another work uniform.

9. Cindy Sherman (b. 1954)

The Academic Angle: Sherman is the ultimate postmodern chameleon. As a central figure of the "Pictures Generation," she uses herself as the model in all of her photographic works, yet none are self-portraits. In her groundbreaking Untitled Film Stills, she staged herself as various female archetypes from B-movies and film noir. In doing so, she brilliantly deconstructs stereotypes, identity, and the male gaze, showing that personality itself can be a kind of unstable, media-influenced performance. Her work is fundamental to understanding photography and identity politics in the contemporary era.

Quirky Fact: Despite the theatricality of her work, Sherman is intensely private. She works entirely alone in her studio—as photographer, model, stylist, and makeup artist—and has said that if anyone else were in the room, she would be too self-conscious to create her characters.

10. Louise Bourgeois (1911-2010)

The Academic Angle: Bourgeois is the great matriarch of psychological sculpture. Though she was active for decades, her profound influence wasn't fully recognized until late in her career. Her work plumbs the depths of human emotion—fear, abandonment, jealousy, and rage—drawing on her own traumatic childhood. From her early wooden "Personages" to her terrifyingly tender spider sculptures (the famous Maman), and her disturbing "Cells," she created a deeply personal vocabulary to explore the body, memory, and the subconscious that has inspired generations of artists.

Quirky Fact: Bourgeois hosted a famous "Sunday Salon" at her Chelsea townhouse for decades. Young artists and critics would bring their work to be praised or, more often, brutally and honestly critiqued by the formidable artist, who would hold court, often still in her bathrobe. It was a legendary rite of passage in the New York art world.